The Athletic Football Show on Jameis Winston

PodcastWeek 3 PreviewSeptember 25, 2026

From the episode

I really hope that the Jameis Winston version of this offense is more watchable than it was last week. His arm just seems like it might be shot.

Mentioned at 108:21 – 108:35

STACKED’s take

Negative signalProjection

Jameis Winston's arm strength appears diminished, hurting the Giants' offense

The source questions the viability of the Giants' offense under Jameis Winston, noting that his arm strength appears to be shot, making the offense difficult to watch and limiting its effectiveness.

Jameis WinstonQB · NYGPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight

Jameis WinstonPositiveNews

Giants backup QB mentioned as unlikely trade target; Giants in playoff contention and would not trade until Dart returns. Ravens passing game coordin...

Reddit /r/fantasyfootball

Jameis WinstonPositiveNews

Prime Jameis Winston ahh line [Quoted](

SleeperNFL

Jameis WinstonPositiveRole

Winston's $13M extension reflects value as veteran leader and mentor to young QBs.

Big Blue View

Jameis WinstonNeutralRole

Jameis Winston went 2-1-1 as Giants starter before McCarthy trade.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Jameis WinstonNeutralRole

Jameis Winston started after Dart injury but lacked consistency for long-term solution.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Jameis WinstonNeutralRole

Winston kept Giants afloat as backup; fine for short-term role.

Yahoo Sports NFL

From the episode

STACKED’s take

More on Jameis Winston and from The Athletic Football Show