From the episode

This is not a tier one quarterback. This is not a tier two quarterback. I'm struggling to call him a tier three quarterback right now. He has been bad this year. The decision making has been atrocious... he's throwing it into double coverage... he's getting picked off... it doesn't look like he gives a shit that he's making bad decisions.

STACKED’s take

Negative signalProjection

Herbert's atrocious decision-making and nonchalant YOLO picks resemble late Cutler.

Drake May assesses Justin Herbert as no longer a tier-two quarterback but struggling to call him tier-three; his decision-making has been atrocious with YOLO picks and YOLO opportunities for defenses every single game. He throws into double coverage in indefensible ways—seam routes with no shot of being open between corner and safety—and gets picked off with a nonchalant demeanor reminiscent of late-career Jay Cutler, appearing not to care about making bad decisions in one-possession games.

Justin Herbert headshotJustin HerbertQB · LACPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight