James' lack of touches and Black's draft capital advantage limit his path to No. 2 back role.

James, the No. 147 overall pick from last year's draft (second-year fifth-rounder), was rarely active in 2025, making just three appearances and failing to notch an offensive touch. He and third-round rookie Kaelon Black have similar skill-sets as early-down box checkers who don't catch many passes, but Black has better draft capital as the 'new guy.' While experience under Shanahan is valuable, James lacks the opportunity to emerge as the No. 2 back, with Black holding the advantage. Behind McCaffrey, an injury would lead to an ad hoc committee rather than a clear No. 2 back.