Source + player page
NFL: The Insiders fantasy football takes on Justin Herbert
Every source-backed podcast insight STACKED has extracted from NFL: The Insiders about Justin Herbert.
27
Insights
7
Positive
19
Negative
Insight ledger
All NFL: The Insiders insights about Justin Herbert
NegativeProjectionOct 19, 2026
Caleb He identifies Justin Herbert as the central question for the Chargers' 0-6 start. He notes that 'even for the harshest of critics of Justin Herbert, this season's a different level of what we've seen from him.' Caleb He asks whether Herbert dislikes McDaniel's offense or is uncomfortable behind a second- and third-string offensive line, but emphasizes the team 'has to definitively answer that question of what is wrong with him' because his performance this season is historically poor.NegativeRoleOct 16, 2026
Justin Herbert doesn't seem to have a supporting cast in the Chargers backfield; the source cites massive issues on the offensive line and questions about his supporting cast as reasons for the Chargers' poor start.NegativeProjectionOct 15, 2026
Herbert has looked unfocused and is throwing the easiest interceptions of his entire career; even for people who criticize him at the highest level, the interceptions he's throwing this year are totally different and at a different level than anything he has attempted before—it's like he's just not seeing defenders.NegativeProjectionOct 12, 2026
Herbert has been pressured on 43.8% of his dropbacks this season, the second-highest rate among qualified quarterbacks and above his previous career high of 41.2% last season. The source notes he appears worn down by the offensive line struggles and pressure, describing him as looking "worn out" despite a large sample size of previous greatness. At 0-5, the Chargers' vibes are at their worst, though the source still considers Herbert QB1 in his draft class and is not moving off him after five games.NegativeBustOct 12, 2026
Justin Herbert has looked sloppy through five weeks with fumbles being a recurring problem, inaccuracy, and poor decision-making; he had an interception in the second half where he was staring at the defender; the source expresses concern about his performance and uncertainty about whether the team will make changes.NegativeProjectionOct 7, 2026
Justin Herbert has looked lost, with his completion percentage dipping below 60% for the first time. He has already thrown six interceptions on throws of 10+ yards, matching his total from all of last season.NegativeUsageOct 6, 2026
Justin Herbert is struggling in a complex new offensive scheme while dealing with a depleted offensive line, forcing him to play hero ball and leading to forced throws that negatively impact the entire offensive operation.NegativeUsageOct 6, 2026
Justin Herbert remains one of the most pressured quarterbacks in the league, raising questions about the team's ability to protect and elevate him.NegativeProjectionOct 5, 2026
Justin Herbert is struggling significantly, looking like a shell of his potential. He threw two interceptions against Seattle and appears frustrated, with his decision-making and accuracy failing to meet expectations early in the season.NegativeUsageOct 3, 2026
Justin Herbert is struggling in the new Chargers offense, having thrown more interceptions on deep passes through three games than in the entirety of the previous two seasons combined. The offense ranks 29th in scoring and leads the league in pre-snap penalties.NegativeProjectionOct 1, 2026
The source notes that Justin Herbert has struggled significantly this season. It is stated that it would require the 'best game of Justin Herbert's season' for the Chargers to keep their upcoming matchup against Seattle close.NegativeProjectionOct 1, 2026
Justin Herbert has not been himself this season, and his performance is being hampered by the Chargers' poor special teams, which ranks last in average starting field position differential at negative 9.1 yards, forcing the offense to constantly dig out of holes.NegativeUsageSep 30, 2026
Justin Herbert is off to a slow start with more interceptions than touchdowns and a sub-60% completion percentage. Head coach Jim Harbaugh has publicly criticized Herbert's decision-making, and the team may need to simplify the complex offensive scheme to get him back on track.NegativeProjectionSep 28, 2026
The source is worried about Justin Herbert's performance, citing career-worst metrics through three games: a -3.8% completion percentage over expected, a 59.1% completion rate, and a negative EPA per dropback. The source notes a lack of urgency and nonchalant play style, particularly on deep throws, contrasting his current effort unfavorably with Josh Allen's intensity.NegativeProjectionSep 28, 2026
Justin Herbert is struggling significantly, posting a career-low completion percentage over expected (-3.8%) and making uncharacteristic, poor decisions. The source expresses genuine worry, noting this is a new low for his career.NegativeProjectionSep 25, 2026
Lance Zerline notes the Chargers are the most disappointing team through two weeks, citing a lack of offensive effectiveness, poor interior line play, and a brutal upcoming schedule that includes four road games in the next five weeks.NegativeUsageSep 23, 2026
Justin Herbert is struggling with turnovers, including a three-turnover game against the Raiders. While some issues are attributed to teammates, Herbert has also made poor decisions, such as unnecessary deep shots into double coverage.NegativeProjectionSep 15, 2026
Justin Herbert struggled in the Chargers' loss, throwing an interception and failing to overcome a double-digit deficit at home.NegativeUsageSep 14, 2026
Justin Herbert struggled to maintain chemistry with receivers other than Ladd McConkie, leading to a frustrated performance and a late-game interception caused by pressure and a lack of reliable options.NegativeMatchupSep 11, 2026
Brian Flores's defensive scheme, specifically his quarters fire zone, is designed to force quarterbacks like Justin Herbert into mistakes by creating pressure and confusing coverage, even when wide-open windows exist.PositiveUsageSep 9, 2026
Ian Rappaport expects Justin Herbert to thrive under new offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel, predicting that Herbert will stretch defenses vertically and horizontally in ways not previously seen in this offense.PositiveRoleAug 26, 2026
Herbert is deeply immersed in the new offense, showing high dedication and ownership. He is frequently seen studying notes in the QB room, and teammates describe his commitment as locked in.PositiveRoleJul 14, 2026
Justin Herbert benefits from Mike McDaniels' offensive scheme with the Chargers, which will feature more moving pocket plays and bootlegs to support Omarion Hampton's running lanes.PositiveProjectionJul 9, 2026
Herbert is getting a significant offensive system upgrade with Mike McDaniel as the new offensive coordinator for the Chargers. McDaniel is changing Herbert's footwork, moving his shotgun snap stance to have his left foot forward instead of right foot forward to fit the timing of his offense. Timing is king with McDaniel; at the peak of his time with Tua, they were scoring 70 points and leading the league in scoring. McDaniel watched every throw Herbert has thrown in his career and put together a presentation of 100+ throws to show what he could do better, with the goal of speeding up his progressions and time to throw.PositiveRoleJun 27, 2026
Justin Herbert is a key weapon for the Chargers under new head coach Mike McDaniels, who is focused on improving the offense's efficiency through better footwork and quarterback mechanics to get receivers the ball in stride for more yards after the catch, rather than overhauling the entire system.PositiveRoleJun 27, 2026
Mike McDaniel is working on improving Justin Herbert's footwork this offseason to help him get rid of the ball quicker and deliver receivers in stride for more yards after the catch; Steve Weiss praises McDaniel's humility in acknowledging he doesn't need to blow up the offense with an elite QB like Herbert.PositiveProjectionJun 27, 2026
Herbert walks into a rich offensive situation with the Chargers under Mike McDaniel; he has elite weapons including Omari and Hampton at running back, David Njoku at tight end, Ladd McConkie and other quality receivers, and an offensive line getting Rashawn Slater and Joe Alt back.