Source + player page

Davis Mattek fantasy football takes on Kyler Murray

Every source-backed video insight STACKED has extracted from Davis Mattek about Kyler Murray.

21
Insights
13
Positive
7
Negative
Insight ledger

All Davis Mattek insights about Kyler Murray

NegativeProjectionSep 28, 2026
Murray is not a viable QB play and has lost the athleticism that differentiated him; he had only ~20 rushing yards and was outrushed by Tyler Shuck. Davis Mattek explicitly states 'Kyler is not good at football' and was unwilling to compromise the lineup to play Murray over Shuck despite similar projections. Murray projected for 16.4 points vs. Shuck's 19.4 points—a 3-point gap larger than Mattek initially realized when he swapped Shuck for Kyler in his lineup solely for clean sweep equity purposes, a decision he later regretted.
PositiveProjectionJul 24, 2026
The source drafted Kyler Murray with high conviction at pick 153, stating there is 'no report that could come out from the Vikings that would make me feel differently' and arguing it is 'a legitimate impossibility that JJ McCarthy plays well enough in training camp and in the preseason to unseat Kyler Murray.' The source emphasized Murray's historical EPA per play advantage over multiple starting quarterbacks (CJ Stroud, Trevor Lawrence, Cam Newton, Jake Browning, Gino Smith, Caleb Williams, Tyler Shuck, Mac Jones, Daniel Jones, Sam Darnold) over the last 10 years, positioning Murray as a clear upgrade over McCarthy. The source dismissed a report claiming both quarterbacks would compete for the starting position at season start, calling it 'lying,' and framed Kevin O'Connell's public messaging as good coaching while maintaining Murray is the clear starter.
PositiveProjectionNo date
Davis Mattek defends Kyler Murray's quarterback quality, noting he has the best pass catchers he's ever had and is in a good system; EPA per play comparison shows Murray at the same level as Bo Nix and better than Derek Carr, Mariota, Mayfield, Cousins, Stroud, Tannehill, Darnold, and Lawrence, characterizing him as 'a pretty fine quarterback' in a system without infrastructure to be a running team. Mattek also emphasizes Murray's role security, stating 'Kyler is starting 17 games if he's healthy.'