Source + player page

Fantasy Football with Ian Hartitz fantasy football takes on Tyler Warren

Every source-backed video insight STACKED has extracted from Fantasy Football with Ian Hartitz about Tyler Warren.

24
Insights
13
Positive
5
Negative
Insight ledger

All Fantasy Football with Ian Hartitz insights about Tyler Warren

PositiveProjectionOct 8, 2026
Warren is ranked TE11 but has underperformed significantly. He had 9 catches for 50 yards in Week 4 with 5.7 yards per catch and 4.8 yards per target, dead last among 28 qualified tight ends. He has not had a target more than 15 yards downfield all year, limiting both yardage and touchdown upside. Daniel Jones has been statistically one of the worst quarterbacks in football, and Warren only received 5 targets last week despite the Colts having limited receiving options (no Alec Pierce, no Keenan Allen). Ian Hartitz wants to move him down even further, noting the Colts have one of the toughest schedules for tight ends over weeks 5-10 and neither Warren nor the offense is playing good football.
PositiveProjectionSep 24, 2026
Tyler Warren is ranked TE9 despite being consensus preseason TE4, with Ian Hartitz describing this as 'panicking a little' about Warren. Season stats show 2.8 yards per target, third-lowest among 33 tight ends with 5+ targets (dead last if threshold raised to 6 targets). The Colts offense lacks downfield threats with Alec Pierce on IR; Darius Slayton, Ashton Dulin, and Keenan Allen are the field-stretchers. Hartitz projects Warren as likely to repeat 5-catch, 20-yard performances dependent on TD scoring and explicitly states he can see himself lowering Warren even more as the week progresses.
NegativeProjectionNo date
Warren is ranked TE9, which feels high given his poor efficiency. Despite two touchdowns, Warren has only 18 catches for 89 yards this season (under 5 yards per catch) through three games, with only one catch of 10+ yards downfield and minimal usage in the wildcat/gadget role despite his Penn State background. Ian Hartitz suspects it's a rough stretch rather than permanent decline but expresses uncertainty about whether to sell Warren or acknowledge he's producing okay despite being really bad. Warren and Colston Loveland are among the only tight ends with 8+ targets averaging under 5 yards per target.
PositiveProjectionNo date
JJ Zachariason ranks Tyler Warren as tight end four, placing him below Brock Bowers (TE1), Coulson Loveland (TE2), and Trey McBride (TE3). Tyler Warren is one of just six rookie tight ends to post top-12 PPR points-per-game numbers over the past decade, joining Brock Bowers, Harold Fannon, Sam Laaporta, Kyle Pitts, and Evan Engram. Zachariason projects Tyler Warren as one of only five tight ends projected to lead his team in targets, supported by his underneath role that suits a potentially hobbled Daniel Jones with reduced arm strength post-Achilles injury.
PositiveBreakoutNo date
Tyler Warren is positioned as a potential breakout tight end for the Colts, described as "Brock Bowers light." As a rookie, he led the team in targets despite Michael Pitman's 111 targets, and with Pitman gone, Warren is expected to see even more volume. Already ranked inside the top five at tight end; positioned as a potential goal-line rushing touchdown beneficiary if he becomes his team's primary red-zone option, which could unlock significant upside. Matt Harmon breaks his usual tight end strategy (elite guys or wait late) to draft Warren in the fifth round.
NegativeProjectionNo date
Ryan Heath views Tyler Warren as part of the consensus top-three tight ends but expresses uncertainty about his trajectory. Warren's rookie season stats were comparable to Brock Bowers' rookie year, and he had a hotter start than Colson Loveland despite being two years older with five years at Penn State as a backup. His early-season success came off play-action and RPO when the Colts offense was leading the league in passing yards per game and top-five in red zone visits, though Heath views him more as a beneficiary of that system than a driver. However, Heath has concerns about Warren's durability given the Colts' quarterback situation—Daniel Jones is coming off a right Achilles tear and may not be at 100% in week one, which Heath frames as a concern for Warren's fantasy outlook, though less severe than for Jonathan Taylor.
PositiveRoleNo date
Ian Hartitz identifies Tyler Warren as the Colts' de facto number one receiver, positioned similarly to Brock Bowers. Warren led the team in targets as a rookie last year and is poised to see increased volume this year with Michael Pittman's 111 targets removed from the offense. Daniel Jones' injury recovery may limit his rushing, forcing quicker passes that favor Warren's skill set; Warren can be schemed up in multiple ways and used out of the backfield, a role he performed in college. Hartitz breaks his typical tight end strategy to draft Warren in the fifth round.