Footballguys on Christian McCaffrey
From the article
413 reasons. That's the number of touches Christian McCaffrey had last year, a career high. History shows that running backs who've eclipsed that 400-touch mark tend to break down the following year, whether it's due to missed time with injury or a general decline in efficiency.
STACKED’s take
McCaffrey's 413 touches and age 30 create unsustainable injury risk; history shows 400+ touch seasons precede major brea
The source identifies McCaffrey as a screaming bust pick in Round 1, emphasizing age and workload risk. At 30 years old entering his 10th season, McCaffrey logged a career-high 413 total touches in 2025 (311 carries and 102 receptions) across 900+ snaps, compounded by a preseason injury concern. Historical precedent is damning: the last time McCaffrey exceeded 400 touches was 2019, and in the two subsequent seasons he missed 14 games both times. When McCaffrey topped 2,000 total yards in prior seasons, he missed 14 games in the following year both times. The source argues that paying a top-five pick for a 30-year-old with this wear-and-tear, lingering health concerns, and historical injury patterns leaves zero margin for error. While healthy McCaffrey offers Tier 1 upside and top-five RB potential, the downside risk of age-related decline and injury recurrence makes him a poor value relative to alternatives like Puka Nacua, Jonathan Taylor, and Amon-Ra St. Brown available at similar ADP.
Christian McCaffreyRB · SFPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight