FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast on Mike Evans

PodcastWeek 1 Start/Sit: The Toughest Fantasy Football Lineup Decisions (Ep. 2185)September 12, 2026

Play the episode audio

From the episode

A.j. Brown. Like strongly prefers Mike Evans over Josh Downs in a start/sit decision, saying 'It's Evans. It's not close.'

Mentioned at 23:55 – 24:05

STACKED’s take

Positive signalProjection

Mike Evans is a strong start over Josh Downs this week.

Mike EvansWR · SFPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight

Mike EvansNegativeProjection

Evans at 33; aging 49ers core may not sustain another full season.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Mike EvansNegativeInjury

Evans sidelined with Achilles injury; 49ers managing recovery with no firm return timeline.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Mike EvansPositiveRole

Evans is the clear No. 1 in a capable 49ers receiver room.

Niners Nation

Mike EvansPositiveRole

Evans returns as 49ers' clear No. 1 receiver in high-octane offense.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Mike EvansNeutralMatchup

Potential Godwin reunion in SF could create fantasy value with Evans

ESPN Fantasy Football

Mike EvansPositiveDepth Chart

Evans' return bolsters 49ers' offensive depth chart.

Niners Nation