Source + player page
Underdog Fantasy Football Show fantasy football takes on Jonathan Taylor
Every source-backed podcast insight STACKED has extracted from Underdog Fantasy Football Show about Jonathan Taylor.
14
Insights
10
Positive
1
Negative
Insight ledger
All Underdog Fantasy Football Show insights about Jonathan Taylor
PositiveProjectionSep 30, 2026
Taylor is ranked RB4 by the source, slightly higher than consensus RB6, and placed in A-tier against Washington. With Daniel Jones available, he is RB1 overall and RB3 in usage, averaging over 100 rushing yards and 1.25 rushing touchdowns per game. The Commanders' defense is weakened with Leo Chennault out for the season with neck surgery and Frankie Lubin potentially returning but not guaranteed to play. The Commanders' linebackers are on their fourth and fifth strings, creating a gettable environment. However, on-off splits with Alex Pierce show significant drops in efficiency when Pierce is off the field (30th in yards per carry and contact per attempt vs. second and fourth with Pierce on).NegativeMatchupSep 23, 2026
Taylor faces a tough Texans defense, but the matchup may not be as difficult as expected. The Texans have defensive issues at tackle and edge depth, with Jadavion Clowney missing time. Taylor had 86 rushing yards plus 36 receiving yards against Houston in week 13 last year (when Daniel Jones was injured and the Colts used a backup QB in week 18). The Colts are ninth in scoring despite two difficult early matchups, and Shane Steichen's offense is competent, suggesting Taylor can still produce in this spot.PositiveProjectionSep 23, 2026
Taylor is one of only four running backs averaging over 25 fantasy points per game, with the next closest (DeAndre Swift) at 21 PPG—a significant gap. He's performed well against tough defenses (Ravens, Chiefs) and now faces the Texans, another tough matchup, but the Colts are catching them at the right time. Taylor has increased his passing game role with 7 catches for 63 yards through two weeks, putting him on pace for almost 60 catches (career high). He's also a pivotal red zone player, especially inside the 10-yard line, where he should see increased volume given Josh Downs is the WR1 and Tyler Warren has been the primary TD target.NegativeRoleSep 23, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is a red zone weapon for the Colts alongside Tyler Warren; the source notes the offense will need to generate explosive plays from the run game because consistent production through the air is unlikely.PositiveProjectionSep 17, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is an S-tier RB. In 14 games with Daniel Jones, he has been the RB1 or RB2 in usage. Despite the Colts being touchdown underdogs against the Chiefs, Taylor looked spry and nimble in Week 1, and the team is committed to the run game regardless of game script.PositiveUsageSep 14, 2026
Jonathan Taylor looked excellent, rushing 19 times for 98 yards and two touchdowns despite the Colts' offensive struggles.NegativeProjectionSep 8, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is ranked as the RB5. While he is a volume-heavy back with no backfield competition, his production is highly dependent on game script (drastic splits between wins and losses). The source notes that while the Ravens' defense is a tough matchup, Taylor's potential for increased passing-game usage—especially if Daniel Jones is less mobile post-injury—keeps him in the top tier.PositiveProjectionAug 31, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is a high-floor RB3 who dominated in Colts wins last season, averaging 30.5 half-PPR points in those games. He was the RB1 overall in usage through the first 13 weeks of last season. With Daniel Jones no longer a threat for goal-line carries, Taylor remains the focal point of Shane Steichen's offense.PositiveProjectionAug 19, 2026
Ranked 9th overall in full PPR; Saquon Barkley has him flipped with CeeDee Lamb in half PPR but prefers current full PPR ranking; new offensive coordinator may increase passing work and goal-line reps; both Colts and Eagles use tush push, creating potential upside.PositiveProjectionAug 17, 2026
Jonathan Taylor has been moved up to the RB5 spot, ahead of Christian McCaffrey, due to his consistent fantasy production and the uncertainty surrounding McCaffrey's health. Taylor averaged over 30 half-PPR points in games the Colts won last season.NegativeProjectionJul 29, 2026
Jonathan Taylor's production heavily dependent on game script and Colts' win total. When Colts in negative game script, Taylor not as involved as other top backs. Colts currently favored for only six games heading into season versus eight wins last year. If Colts win only six games, Taylor season could be viewed as disappointment despite strong efficiency. Biggest gap between wins and losses in fantasy scoring among top backs. Last month of season showed RB7 in expected points with poor efficiency.PositiveProjectionJul 29, 2026
Jonathan Taylor ranked seventh overall. RB3 overall usage over past three seasons under Shane Steichen with some low-end RB1 moments and elite RB1 moments. First 13 weeks when Daniel Jones was healthy, Taylor was RB1 overall on RB2 usage in half-PPR. In Colts' eight wins last season, averaged over 30 half-PPR points per game. Led league with 6 yards per carry and 47-48% success rate in opening 10 games before Jones injury. Owns 84% of Colts backfield touches; only addition was seventh-round rookie. Entire focal point of offense with Alec Pierce injured, Josh Jones uncertain, no Michael Pittman. Strong offensive line. Nearly 100 rushing yards per game average.PositiveRoleJul 28, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is the eighth overall pick on Yahoo and benefits from Shane Steichen's play-calling, which ranks among the top designers of the run game with strong 10+ yard design run rates. Steichen's proven track record with run game design supports Taylor's draft positioning.PositiveValueJul 28, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is the eighth overall pick on Yahoo and benefits from Shane Steichen's play-calling, which ranks in the top tier for 10-plus yard design run rates. Steichen's offensive scheme is designed to generate explosive plays in the run game, positioning Taylor as a high-value target in early rounds.