PlayerProfiler Fantasy Football Podcast Network on J.J. McCarthy

PodcastFantasy Empire - Players We Are Buying & SellingSeptember 17, 2026

From the episode

the word around here is that basically uh jj mccarthy is uncoachable... he just doesn't want to listen to anything that o'connell tells him... seems like he's got a you know way too much ego

Mentioned at 89:46 – 90:09

STACKED’s take

Negative signalDepth Chart

McCarthy is demoted due to being uncoachable.

The source reports that J.J. McCarthy is considered uncoachable and has too much ego, leading to his demotion to QB3 behind Carson Wentz.

J.J. McCarthyQB · NYGPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight

J.J. McCarthyNeutralRole

McCarthy best suited for game manager role; would benefit from elite RB support

Yahoo Sports NFL

J.J. McCarthyPositiveRole

McCarthy showing elite skills and maturity with Giants after rough Vikings tenure.

Big Blue View

J.J. McCarthyPositiveProjection

McCarthy shows marked improvement with Giants; poised and calm without INT issues.

Big Blue View

J.J. McCarthyPositiveRole

McCarthy fits the Giants' offensive system, per Nguyen's analysis.

NFL - The Athletic

J.J. McCarthyPositiveValue

McCarthy avoids bye-week concerns and offers streaming value with Giants' passing focus.

Yahoo Fantasy Football

J.J. McCarthyNeutralRole

McCarthy earned his trade; Vikings didn't give up on talent, but on performance.

Yahoo Sports NFL

From the episode

STACKED’s take

More on J.J. McCarthy and from PlayerProfiler Fantasy Football Podcast Network