Source + player page

Dawgs By Nature fantasy football takes on Shedeur Sanders

Every source-backed article insight STACKED has extracted from Dawgs By Nature about Shedeur Sanders.

80
Insights
11
Positive
32
Negative
Insight ledger

All Dawgs By Nature insights about Shedeur Sanders

NegativeProjectionSep 7, 2026
The Athletic's Mike Sando ranked Sanders last overall in his annual QB tier ranking, placing him in the lowest tier alongside Deshaun Watson. The Quarterback Index (QBI) metric scored Sanders at 47, significantly below all other starting QBs; his 2025 season performance was approximately 40% worse than the next-ranked quarterbacks (JJ McCarthy at 76, Tua Tagovailoa at 78, Cam Ward at 78). The QBI metric isolates quarterback performance from supporting cast contributions, crediting only what the quarterback provides on a per-play basis, yet Sanders still ranked last. Sando's commentary on Sanders was notably harsh: 'I'd sleep like a baby if I got to play him every week.' SB Nation's quarterback data also had Sanders' 2025 performance at the bottom of the league.
NegativeProjectionSep 7, 2026
Joel Bitonio, a 13-time Pro Bowl offensive lineman who saw Sanders in live games and practice, identified critical development gaps: Sanders lacks anticipation and takes too long to throw. Bitonio noted that while Sanders shows improvement from his rookie year and looks downfield more, he isn't ready for the NFL pace; taking over three seconds to throw is unmanageable even with elite pass protection. Sanders is productive only when he has a clean pocket and must learn to process faster and get the ball out quicker.
NegativeProjectionSep 5, 2026
Sanders is part of the Browns QB rotation that underperformed in 2025, combining with Joe Flacco and Dillon Gabriel to produce only 2,808 passing yards (second-fewest in NFL) and 16 touchdowns against 18 interceptions. The source indicates the Browns will need significantly better QB play in 2026, requiring approximately 600 additional passing yards (36 per game) to reach playoff-caliber performance benchmarks set by Eagles (3,303) and Steelers (3,440).
NegativeDepth ChartAug 31, 2026
Sanders lost quarterback competitions in back-to-back seasons: last year to aged Joe Flacco and undersized Dillon Gabriel, and this year to Deshaun Watson (who hasn't been good for half a decade and missed a year and a half). The addition of Joe Milton to the Browns would likely lead to Sanders' departure, as Milton's experience and athletic profile make him the preferred backup over the rookie Taylen Green; Sanders' repeated losses to inferior competition suggest the organization is not high on his talent.
NegativeRoleAug 30, 2026
Named as backup quarterback behind Deshaun Watson for Week 1; the source describes this as an unpopular decision by head coach Todd Monken, with fan sentiment heavily negative (90%+ opposed to Watson starting). One commenter (Spidey) noted that in training camp and preseason, there was not much difference in TD/INT results between Sanders and Watson, but Watson appeared to have better command in the huddle and at the line of scrimmage, which influenced Monken's decision.
NegativeDepth ChartAug 27, 2026
Lost the QB competition to Deshaun Watson and has been relegated to backup role. The source states 'the path to any future for Shedeur Sanders in Cleveland is narrowing' but notes that the path 'has not completely vanished because I have no faith that Deshaun Watson can stay healthy for an entire season or be productive enough to keep the job.' Sanders, a fifth-round draft choice from last year, was the primary competition to Watson, but the starter decision signals the organization's lack of confidence in his near-term prospects.
NegativeRoleAug 25, 2026
Lost the Browns QB competition to Deshaun Watson despite widespread assumption that Watson's poor preseason performance and critical press conference would lead to Sanders winning the starting job. The source notes that 'everyone assuming that Deshaun Watson's performance on the field and in the press conference closed the door on him and would lead to Shedeur Sanders getting the starting job,' but head coach Todd Monken ultimately chose Watson as the Week 1 starter for 2026, leaving Sanders as a backup option with the 2027 draft class lurking as potential future alternatives.
NegativeRoleAug 23, 2026
Sanders is the other contender for the starter's role after one of the worst rookie seasons in the past 25 years. His key selling point is that he is not Deshaun Watson. From an on-field perspective, Sanders has not shown enough to be called QB1, but from an off-field perspective he is the call 100 times out of 100. Starting Sanders would finally put to rest excuses about his poor rookie performance, as he will have had several weeks of practice with the first-team offense and all starters in the huddle for Week 1. Even if the Browns open 0-2, there will still be grace given to the team with Sanders as starter.
NegativeProjectionAug 22, 2026
Sanders scored a 62% on his preseason test against Chicago—below the 70% passing threshold—and failed to shorten the gap in the QB competition with Deshaun Watson. The source identifies slow processing and hesitant operation as key concerns: Sanders wasn't processing quickly enough, was slow to get in and out of the huddle, and went through progressions at a slower pace than Watson. While Sanders had one nice throw to Luke Floriea and took shots downfield, the interception (an overthrow) and overall performance were not impressive. As a second-year player in a new system, Sanders is facing an uphill climb and now must chase Watson heading into the Buffalo game, where time may run out on the youngster.
NegativeRoleAug 21, 2026
QB Shedeur Sanders is scheduled to start the preseason game against Buffalo on Saturday, August 23, 2026. During the joint practice, Sanders led a two-minute drill drive that advanced to 11 yards from the end zone, including a 4th-and-1 completion to TE Harold Fannin to keep the drive alive. The drive ultimately came up short when his pass to WR Denzel Boston in the corner of the end zone was broken up. There is a noted stigma among opposing defenses regarding Sanders, with a Bills defender overheard making a comment about Sanders' checkdown tendencies, though Sanders did complete a pass to WR Malachi Corley over the middle during the practice.
NegativeProjectionAug 18, 2026
Sanders is in the running for the starting QB job; his naysayers state he needs more development and only started in college because his dad was the head coach, with teams that never won a conference title and only played in one bowl game where they were blown out. His followers believe he is the next superstar QB in the league, a cross between Michael Vick, Tom Brady, and Johnny Unitas. He will need a great showing in the final two preseason games while being inserted into Cleveland's first-team offense against the opponent's first-team defense to prove he can win the starting job and play at an elite level.
NegativeProjectionAug 15, 2026
Backup QB Shedeur Sanders showed mixed preseason performance against mostly backups. He started the second half well with a couple of good throws including one where he drifted in the pocket through pressure, and had nice ball placement to Gage Larvadain on the sideline in a Cover-2 hole. However, everything felt slow overall including time in the huddle, and he threw an interception on an overthrow by about five yards, though the receiver (Malachi Corley) may have run the wrong depth. The source notes Deshaun Watson left the door wide-open for Sanders to run through next week.
NegativeProjectionAug 15, 2026
If Sanders loses the starting QB competition to Watson, the Browns could explore trading him. The source notes it's not certain but cannot be ruled out; most likely a trade would involve Sanders for a defender on the bubble (CB or DE) from another team with depth. Sanders could build trade value with a strong preseason performance, but if he doesn't win the starting job and shows only flashes, Cleveland might trade him to prepare for the 2027 NFL draft rather than keep him as a backup.
NegativeRoleAug 15, 2026
In his second year with the Browns, Sanders is competing for the starting QB job against veteran Deshaun Watson but is running into adversity in the competition. Inconsistencies or lack of progress in crucial areas have shifted the quarterback situation; Watson is starting Week 1 of the preseason against Chicago. The source notes Sanders is viewed as a 'developmental quarterback' with limitations from his Colorado offense background, struggling in key aspects like presnap reads and progressions.