Mattek Fantasy Football artwork

2026 Sleeper Running Backs Nobody Believes In (I Do)

STACKED extracted the fantasy-relevant player signal from this video and kept the full transcript here for context.

14 min
Duration
Estimated from transcript
May 26, 2026
Published
Tue, May 26, 2026
10
Player insights
8
Players mentioned
Topics
Keaton MitchellNicholas SingletonAaron JonesDemond ClaiborneJacory Croskey-MerrittJordan MasonTony PollardTyjae Spears
Player analysis

Player insights

10

Aaron Jones

PositiveProjection10:30

Aaron Jones was not particularly efficient in his most recent season, posting one of his worst NFL campaigns by snap rate and yards per carry. His yards per game were the lowest since his rookie year; he increased passing-game usage but his yards per target dropped to 4.9. Game logs showed inconsistent production, exemplified by a 14-carry, 7.6-point outing. At 31 years old, the source questions his value to the Vikings and suggests the team may move on, creating opportunity for De'Mond Claiborne.

Insight page

Demond Claiborne

PositiveSleeper10:05

Claiborne was the fastest player in college football in 2026 per NCAA ratings and one of the best kick returners, posting a 101-yard return in under 5 seconds. He lands with the Vikings—a team the source likes—behind two aging veterans: Jordan Mason (an average interior rusher with no passing-game utility; fewer than 40 targets in four seasons) and Aaron Jones (inefficient last season with 4.9 yards per target and a 14-carry, 7.6-point outing; lowest yards per game since his rookie year at age 31). Claiborne has the physical tools to impact the running game and will be the primary kick returner, a path to early playing time similar to Isaiah Pacheco's success with Kansas City. The source anticipates Claiborne could earn 5 rushes and 1 target in his first NFL game and is currently undrafted in most leagues, making him a waiver-wire priority.

Insight page

Jacory Croskey-Merritt

PositiveSleeper0:24

Undrafted free agent who started in his first NFL game and finished 2025 as RB7 in week 17 with 105 rushing yards and 2 TDs against Dallas. Now going at pick 114 on Underdog and even later on ESPN/Sleeper mock drafts, despite strong 2025 finish. With Chris Rodriguez departing and Rashad White expected to play the Austin Ekeler third-down role, Croskey-Merritt is positioned to retain the starting role he earned. Ke'Shawn Allen is the only meaningful competition, but Mattek Fantasy Football views Croskey-Merritt as a better distance runner and home-run hitter. Recommended as a premium target on zero RB and hero RB team constructions, with potential to finish inside the top 24 RBs in week one projections.

Insight page

Jordan Mason

NegativeRole10:30

Mason is characterized as an average interior rusher who provides no passing-game utility; over four seasons he has generated fewer than 40 targets, a brutal ratio that means he cannot play on passing downs. This limitation creates opportunity for De'Mond Claiborne in the Vikings backfield, as the offense will need a back who can contribute in the passing game.

Insight page

Keaton Mitchell

PositiveSleeper3:01

Top-five in rushing yards over expectation in 2023 before knee injury. In 2025, Ravens coaching staff clearly wanted to use him despite his size limitations on passing downs and competition from Derrick Henry. Now with the Los Angeles Chargers, he shares a backfield with Damarion Hampton, a top first-round pick who was one of the worst pass-protection RBs in the NFL and lost passing-down snaps to Ke'Shawn Vaughn, fullbacks, and tight ends. Mattek Fantasy Football projects Mitchell at 10.3 fantasy points per game with potential for nine-carry, 68-yard, touchdown-style games. Mitchell has ADP of 144 on Underdog and is likely undrafted in 10-team leagues and a 14th-15th round pick in 12-team leagues. The source emphasizes Mitchell as one of the most important guys to roster and the definition of a sleeper RB this season; he is the Devon Achane to Hampton's Raheem Mostert in the Chargers' McShanny-style zone run scheme.

Insight page
PositiveSleeper4:19

Keeton Mitchell is the source's favorite sleeper RB combination of talent, offensive situation, contingency value, and stand-alone role in the Chargers' McShanny-style zone run scheme. The source projects Mitchell at 10.3 fantasy points per game with potential for nine-carry, 68-yard, touchdown-style games. Mitchell has ADP of 144 on Underdog and is likely undrafted in 10-team leagues and a 14th-15th round pick in 12-team leagues. The source emphasizes Mitchell as one of the most important guys to roster and the definition of a sleeper RB this season.

Insight page

Nicholas Singleton

NegativeSleeper6:48

Day-three RB prospect with breakout potential contingent on a Titans youth movement scenario. Singleton broke out as a true freshman at Penn State but ceded work to Keaton Allen over time while contributing as both rusher and pass-catcher. Mattek Fantasy Football argues Singleton could be a real breakout if the Titans pursue a youth movement (trading/benching Calvin Ridley, out-targeting Wan'Dale Robinson with Cordarrelle Tate, developing Gunner Helm and Kam Ward). Singleton was likely undervalued in the 2026 NFL draft due to a foot injury at the Senior Bowl that prevented him from running the combine; the source estimates his RAS would have been ~9.8 had he competed, comparable to Mike Washington Jr.'s athletic profile. Landing with the Titans—a team expected to run the ball frequently—Singleton has a clear path to playing time as Tony Pollard ages into the injury-risk bracket (28-30 years old) and Tyjae Spears has durability concerns. The source projects Singleton as a core part of the Titans' next winning roster alongside Carnell Tate and Gunner Helm, and explicitly recommends drafting him as the literal last player on your roster in home leagues to monitor his backfield opportunity.

Insight page
NegativeSleeper8:27

Singleton was likely undervalued in the 2026 NFL draft due to a foot injury at the Senior Bowl that prevented him from running the combine; the source estimates his RAS would have been ~9.8 had he competed, comparable to Mike Washington Jr.'s athletic profile. Landing with the Titans—a team expected to run the ball frequently—Singleton has a clear path to playing time as Tony Pollard ages into the injury-risk bracket (28-30 years old) and Tyjae Spears has durability concerns. The source projects Singleton as a core part of the Titans' next winning roster alongside Carnell Tate and Gunner Helm, and explicitly recommends drafting him as the literal last player on your roster in home leagues to monitor his backfield opportunity.

Insight page

Tony Pollard

NegativeRole9:00

At 28-30 years old, Pollard is entering the age bracket where ankle injuries and decline become expected for running backs. The source views Pollard as unlikely to be part of the Titans' next winning roster, suggesting his role and opportunity will diminish as the team pivots toward younger prospects like Nicolas Singleton.

Insight page

Tyjae Spears

NegativeRole9:00

Spears came into the NFL without ACLs and has managed to stay healthy in chunks of his career, though he has not been a model of health overall. The source views him as unlikely to be part of the Titans' next winning roster, suggesting limited long-term role security despite his durability relative to his injury history.

Insight page
Full transcript

Episode Transcript

400
0:00Fantasy football is completely different
0:01in 2026. This is the best the market has
0:04ever been at pricing running backs. So,
0:06finding a running back that's
0:07underpriced, who is a legitimate sleeper
0:09in this draft environment, is quite the
0:11tall task, but that's exactly what I've
0:13done today. I have four sleeper running
0:15backs for the 2026 fantasy football
0:17season. Guys who are going outside the
0:19top 100 picks, who I think can
0:20contribute for our fantasy football
0:22teams this upcoming year. I've got to go
0:24ahead and begin with my guy, Jacory
0:26Croskey-Merritt, who had a better season
0:28last year than you remember. At the end
0:30of the day, he was an undrafted free
0:33agent as pick, a round seven pick, who
0:35barely played in college. He ended up as
0:36a starter in his first ever NFL game,
0:39closed out the season in week 17, the
0:41championship week, against Dallas as the
0:43running back seven with 105 rushing
0:45yards and two rushing touchdowns. Chris
0:48Rodriguez is out the door. Rashad White
0:50is in the door to play that Austin
0:52Ekeler role. Jerick McKinnon is still
0:54technically on the team. Jerome Ford is
0:56still technically on the team. And the
0:57Commanders also selected Chris Rodriguez
1:00on day three of the NFL draft. This is
1:02my breakdown for the 2026 Commanders
1:05backfield. I think that Jacory
1:06Croskey-Merritt is going to be given
1:08every opportunity to win the role that
1:10he had last year, just with no Chris
1:12Rodriguez on the team. Now, is Chris
1:14Rodriguez better than JCM? I frankly did
1:17not think he was. I did see what the
1:19Commanders coaching staff saw in him.
1:20He's a pretty good interior runner. He
1:22is a good goal-line runner. There were
1:24certainly some games and some instances
1:26where I wish that Jacory Croskey-Merritt
1:28was playing much better. This kind of
1:30interstitial area, these games against
1:32Chicago, Dallas, and Kansas City, where
1:34Jayden Daniels was injured or scuffling.
1:37I'm not going to lie, they were not very
1:38fun games to watch. But, as of right
1:41now, we have JCM on Underdog going at
1:44pick 114. He's going even later than
1:46that on some of the big draft software.
1:48So, if you look at ESPN mock drafts or
1:50sleeper mock drafts, he's going much
1:52later than that.
1:53Even if Rashad White plays a very
1:56similar role in Washington that he did
1:58at Tampa Bay, where he's playing on a
1:59lot of third downs. He is such a poor
2:02interior runner that I basically think
2:03the only competition on the roster is
2:06from Penn State's Ke'Shawn Allen.
2:08Ke'Shawn Allen to me is really just like
2:10bigger Jacquory Cross Kemore. I think
2:12JCM is a better distance runner. I think
2:14he's a better home run hitter than
2:16Ke'Shawn. I I don't want to totally
2:18poopoo the chances that Allen ends up
2:20over playing JCM over the course of the
2:22season, but I would I would bet right
2:24now very early on that JCM does end up
2:27being the starting running back for the
2:28Commanders and is very underpriced
2:31inside of that backfield. I would
2:33consider him a premium target on zero
2:36running back teams or even hero running
2:38back teams. Like let's say you take
2:39Jamar Chase in round one and Josh Jacobs
2:42in round two. Maybe you add in a David
2:44Montgomery or By'Shawn Tuten somewhere
2:46in there. JCM is a great fit as a third
2:49or fourth running back on teams like
2:51that and it would not be surprising if
2:52he is inside the top 24 running backs in
2:55terms of week one projection when we get
2:58there. So JCM for the Commanders, I like
3:01a good bit. Of course, I have to bring
3:03up my guy Keaton Mitchell, who his first
3:06season in the NFL, he was top five in
3:08the NFL in rushing yards over
3:10expectation. That was all the way back
3:12in 2023 before he injured his knee. What
3:15I thought was so interesting in 2025 was
3:18that it was pretty clear to me that the
3:20Ravens coaching staff did want to find
3:22ways to use Keaton Mitchell, even though
3:25he's probably too small to play on
3:27passing downs and his backfield mate is
3:29Hall of Famer Derrick Henry. Keaton
3:31Mitchell is now a member of the Los
3:33Angeles Chargers, which is, depending on
3:35your perspective, either a very good or
3:37a very bad situation. He is going to be
3:40sharing a backfield with Damarion
3:41Hampton, who was a top first round pick
3:44last season. Damarion Hampton was one of
3:46the worst pass protection running backs
3:47in the NFL to the point that he was just
3:49no longer playing on passing downs. The
3:51team was playing Ke'Shawn Vaughn over
3:53him. They were playing a fullback
3:55instead of him. They were playing second
3:57tight ends instead of Hampton on obvious
3:59passing downs.
4:00You know, part of that was that the Los
4:02Angeles Chargers offensive line was so
4:04bad. Now, I do expect Hampton to be the
4:06lead running back. What I do think will
4:08be very interesting though will be games
4:10where Keeton Mitchell has the hot hand.
4:12Like you could tell me that in four
4:15games this upcoming season, Keeton
4:17Mitchell actually out-carries Amari
4:19Hampton in games where Hampton is fully
4:21healthy, even in games that the Chargers
4:23win because the obvious comparison to
4:25make is with Mike McDaniel now as the
4:27offensive coordinator for the Los
4:29Angeles Chargers. Keeton Mitchell is the
4:31Devon Achane and Amari Hampton, well, he
4:34is the Raheem Mostert inside of this
4:35backfield. And something that is sort of
4:37interesting about the McShanny kind of
4:39West Coast style offenses is these are
4:42actually run-based offenses. A lot of
4:44people think about Sean McVay, they
4:46think about Kyle Shanahan, and they're
4:47like, "Oh, these guys are wizards in
4:49terms of the play-calling. Their their
4:51quarterbacks are always so efficient."
4:52But it's all downstream of OG Shanahan,
4:55Mike Shanahan, which is, you know, that
4:57zone run scheme that just basically
5:00creates free yards for running backs.
5:02And when guys like Keeton Mitchell get
5:04free rein and they are able to, you
5:06know, make decisions and create space
5:09around the edge, that is a spot where I
5:11could see Keeton Mitchell having games
5:13where he has, you know, plenty of
5:15nine-carry for 68-yard and a
5:17touchdown-style games. I obviously think
5:19he also has a ton of contingent value,
5:22which in general is going to be what a
5:23lot of our sleeper running backs are
5:24this upcoming year. It's going to be a
5:26lot of contingent value guys. A lot of
5:28the backfields are fairly settled. And a
5:30lot of these backfields, the market I
5:32think has a good handle on, you know,
5:33people are smart about fantasy football
5:36in 2026. I mean, that's just the way it
5:38is. People are so much better at this
5:39game than they used to be. But Keeton is
5:42my favorite combination of talent,
5:45offensive situation, contingency value,
5:48and stand-alone role. There have been
5:50multiple backfields over the most recent
5:515 years where we've seen two running
5:53backs were like pretty clearly startable
5:55for fantasy football.
5:57The first thing that has to be true is
5:59that the offense has to be very good. In
6:00fact, we have seen offenses undermine
6:02the Daniel be good enough for two
6:04starting guys. We've also seen offenses
6:06with Justin Herbert have enough points
6:08on the bone for two running backs to be
6:10able to be out there and get fantasy
6:12points. So, I would not be at all
6:13surprised if we saw Keaton be a 10.3
6:17fantasy points per game player and Amari
6:19and Hampton be a 14 and 1/2, 15 and 1/2
6:21fantasy points per game player. But,
6:23Keaton Mitchell is one of the most
6:25important guys for me to get on my
6:26fantasy football teams this year and
6:28average draft position of 144 over on
6:30Underdog. He honestly probably in a lot
6:32of your 10-team leagues is going
6:34undrafted. 12-team leagues, he's going
6:35to be like a 14th, 15th round pick. But,
6:38I think that Keaton Mitchell is
6:39basically the definition of a sleeper
6:42running back this upcoming season and
6:43will be one of my most rostered players.
6:46Moving further down the list, I I'm
6:48going to have to go with my guy Nicholas
6:50Singleton here. This is going to go with
6:52some of our research on ambiguous
6:54backfields. And maybe you would say that
6:56the Tennessee Titans is not an ambiguous
6:58backfield, but I kind of think it is
7:01because Tony Pollard does not
7:02necessarily meet all the definitions of
7:05a clear incumbent running back. Like
7:07Tony Pollard was already giving up a
7:09good amount of work to Tajae Spears.
7:12Nicholas Singleton, who actually was
7:13backfield mates with Keaton Allen,
7:15started out as one of the most
7:16interesting running back prospects in
7:18all of college football, like broke out
7:20as a true freshman at Penn State, ended
7:22up seating work to Keaton Allen over
7:24time, but contributed as both a rusher
7:27and a pass-catcher. And what you think
7:29about Singleton will sort of be what do
7:31you think about the Tennessee Titans? If
7:33you think that Brian Daboll can come in,
7:35reinvigorate the offense, use Tajae
7:37Spears in a role that he was comfortable
7:39in, use Tony Pollard in the role that he
7:41played in last season, then you probably
7:43don't need to be drafting Nicolas
7:44Singleton. If you think there's a chance
7:46that this is a total youth movement
7:47situation, wherein, you know, Calvin
7:50Ridley either gets traded or benched,
7:52Wan'Dale Robinson ends up being
7:53out-targeted by Cordarrelle Tate, we get
7:55a lot of uh my guy Gunner Helm playing
7:57at the tight end position, and it ends
7:59up being a developmental year for Kam
8:01Ward, then it makes total sense to me
8:03that Singleton could be a real breakout.
8:05I mean, one of the things that we do
8:06know about fantasy football that has
8:08been proven true year after year,
8:11is that these day three running back
8:12prospects have a great ability to impact
8:15their teams right away, even when not
8:17very much draft capital was spent on
8:19them, and even if the backfield does
8:21look a little bit crowded ahead of them.
8:22I mean, I think a great example of that
8:24was actually the running back we just
8:25talked about, Jacory Croskey-Merritt
8:27from the prior year, where Brian
8:28Robinson Jr. got traded, Austin Ekeler
8:30got injured, and boom, playing time
8:33showed up right there for him. I would
8:34expect that Singleton probably could
8:36have been drafted much higher actually
8:38in the 2026 NFL draft. He injured his
8:41foot early on in the process at the
8:43Senior Bowl, and as a result, he did not
8:45get to run at the combine. If Nicolas
8:47Singleton had ran at the combine, I
8:49think that his RAS probably would have
8:51been more like a 9.8. I I think he could
8:54have put up a very similar combine to
8:56Mike Washington Jr. And looking at the
8:58Tennessee Titans, I think they're
8:59probably going to be a team that wants
9:01to run the ball good bit. Tony Pollard
9:03is entering into that age bracket, where
9:06you start to expect the ankle turn for a
9:0828, 29, 30-year-old running back more
9:10than you do a 25-year-old running back.
9:12I mean, Tyjae Spears came into the NFL
9:14without ACLs, has found a way to stay
9:16healthy for chunks of his NFL career. He
9:19certainly has not been the model of
9:21health, but I really like Singleton as a
9:22prospect. I think it's a situation where
9:24particularly in the back half of the
9:26season, the team could just be looking
9:28to expand all their options to see who
9:30they have on the roster who could maybe
9:32be the part of their next great roster.
9:34Cuz right, Tony Pollard, Calvin Ridley,
9:36probably even Spears, Daniel Bellinger,
9:38these guys are not going to be a part of
9:40the next great Titans team, of the next
9:42Titans playoff win. But Nicholas
9:44Singleton, Carnell Tate, and Gunner Helm
9:46could certainly be parts of the next
9:49Titan teams to win a playoff game. So I
9:51feel pretty, pretty strongly that
9:53Nicholas Singleton in your home leagues,
9:55I mean he is like a great guy to take as
9:58the literal last player on your roster
10:00and just wait to see what happens inside
10:03of the Tennessee Titans backfield. And
10:05then our final clear sleeper running
10:07back is actually a very similar
10:09situation except on an actually good
10:11team. And that's going to be my guy
10:13De'Mond Claiborne out of Wake Forest.
10:15Now, De'Mond Claiborne was literally the
10:17fastest player in college football last
10:19season if you take the NCAA 2026 ratings
10:23for it. He was also one of the best kick
10:24returners in college football, had a
10:26101-yard kick return that took less than
10:295 seconds. Seriously, one of the most
10:30impressive kick returns that you were
10:32ever going to see.
10:34Claiborne landed in an even better
10:36situation than Singleton where he's got
10:38the two veterans ahead of him in Jordan
10:40Mason who is the Tajae Spears analog and
10:42Aaron Jones who is the Tony who is the
10:45Tony Pollard analog. Claiborne has the
10:47unique ability, I think actually sort of
10:49similar to JCM, to just earn his way
10:53onto the field from game one, week one.
10:56A lot of teams, a lot of people were
10:57actually expecting Aaron Jones to just
10:58move on from the Minnesota Vikings.
11:00Like, what are you getting from a
11:0331-year-old running back at this stage
11:04of their career? I mean, Aaron Jones was
11:06not particularly efficient last season.
11:08It was actually one of his worst NFL
11:10seasons if you look at his snap rates
11:12and his yards per carry. It was the
11:14lowest yards per game he'd had since he
11:16was a rookie. He actually increased his
11:19passing game usage, but his yards per
11:21target was all the way down to 4.9. And
11:24you look at the game logs, I mean it was
11:25just if you were starting Aaron Jones in
11:27fantasy football last year, you were
11:29like, yep. Well, that looks about right.
11:3114 carries for 7.6 points. And the issue
11:34with Jordan Mason is that Jordan Mason
11:36is, I think, a pretty crumulent average,
11:39you know, fine interior rusher, but he
11:41does not give you anything in the
11:43passing game. I mean, over the course of
11:45his career, he has generated fewer than
11:4840 targets in four seasons, which is a
11:50pretty brutal ratio. He's just not going
11:52to be someone who can ever play on the
11:53passing downs. So, Clayborn lands
11:55himself in a backfield with an offense
11:57we like, the McKinnon tree as a coach
12:00with Kevin O'Connell. He has, I think,
12:02the requisite physical abilities to
12:05impact the running game at the NFL
12:07level. And I would anticipate that he
12:09also is going to hurdle, you know, he's
12:11going to he's going to do the biggest
12:12hurdle because he's going to be active
12:14on game days because he is going to be
12:16the primary kick returner for the
12:17Minnesota Vikings. This is one of the
12:19paths to playing time that another day
12:22three NFL pick, uh, that we all loved in
12:24fantasy football, Isaiah Pacheco, was a
12:26day three pick who found himself active
12:28because he was a really good kick
12:29returner for the Kansas City Chiefs. It
12:31was actually Ihmir Smith-Marsette who
12:32was active for the Chiefs last year, as
12:34well. Would not surprise me if Clayborn
12:36comes out and gets something like five
12:37rushes and maybe one target in his very
12:39first NFL game. And no one is taking
12:43De'Shawn Clayborn in your leagues. I
12:44mean, he goes undrafted on Underdog
12:46quite a bit, and you know, not drafted
12:48in in best ball leagues. So, I feel
12:49pretty good about Clayborn. I mean, you
12:51could keep him on your waiver wire speed
12:53dial, but he is going to be the kind of
12:55guy in my home leagues. I'm trying to
12:56beat my buddies, and also I'm trying to,
12:58you know, there's always this thing in
12:59your home leagues where you're trying to
13:00do the coolest pick. De'Shawn Clayborn
13:02is a very cool pick. Your your friends
13:05are going to be like, "Wow, this guy is,
13:06uh, literally so much smarter than me.
13:08How did he know De'Shawn Clayborn was
13:09going to end up starting running back
13:10for the Vikings?" So, those were four
13:12sleeper running backs for 2026. Jacory
13:15Croskey-Merritt, Keaton Mitchell, my guy
13:18Nicholas Singleton, and finally my guy
13:20De'Shawn Clayborn. Make sure that you
13:22are subscribed to this channel for more
13:24fantasy football videos, and you can
13:25check out flockfantasy.com.
13:28Link to that is down in the description
13:30for all of my rankings, best ball tools,
13:32and all that stuff for fantasy football.

More episodes from Mattek Fantasy Football

6