From the episode

The metrics have dropped off even before the injury... I'm going to keep you in the top tier benefit of the doubt still. But not number one benefit of the doubt.

STACKED’s take

NeutralProjection

Mahomes drops to number two following a metric downswing and his first major injury.

Brandon Anderson drops Patrick Mahomes to number two, ending a seven-year streak at the top. The ranking reflects a recent downswing in metrics (EPA, success rate, completion over expectation) and his first major injury (torn ACL), though Anderson maintains he is still in the top tier due to his proven playoff success.

Patrick Mahomes headshotPatrick MahomesQB · KCPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight